AirGradient Forum

New version of indoor unit, request for CO sensor!

Adding a Carbon monoxide (CO) sensor would be a great add-on to this project in a future hardware release!

Or consider a add-on kit that can be user installed in existing devices…

2 Likes

Hi @trlafleur! Thank you for the request. This is well noted. If anyone else in the community has a similar request, please let us know here.

I’m also interested in a carbon monoxide sensor.

1 Like

I would rather see a size reduction in the new version. The AirGradient feels a bit bulky, or perhaps the display is just too small. I hadn’t noticed it before, but compared to the new IKEA sensor, it lacks sleekness. The ability to wall mount is great, but also on the wall, next to light switch it looks odd. Otherwise I’m big fan of it.

I disagree with adding this feature, and I agree with the commenter arguing for a size reduction/more elegant form factor.

For the people who want CO, what is the purpose? It isn’t commonly considered air pollution in the large-area environmental sense. It is considered a dangerous and potentially lethal gas that can build inside enclosed spaces due to combustion. For the latter, there are numerous, cheap CO detector/alarms available. Adding this to air gradient runs up the BOM (and price) without any relationship to what it is really supposed to measure.

It also isn’t actionable in the way that PM is (by a air purifier). For CO, remove yourself from the environment/go outside, and ventilate/eliminate combustion source or exhaust leak.

This request isn’t really any different than radon detector to air gradient. Indoor air problem only, also with many commercially available, cheap tests and detectors.

Typical outdoor air pollutants measured by governments/environmental entities:

PM
O3
Benzene
Nox
Sox

The problem with everything below PM is doing it reliably is vastly more expensive than measuring PM. If air gradient can figure that out, now that would be a win.

Adding CO also carries the risk that someone starts relying on it for safety, which this product is not intended for.

1 Like

I’d like to see a CO function as well.

Many of us live and work in environments with either forced air heating and / or gas cooking. While I agree that a more aesthetic physical design would be great, that along with having to have an additional meter to do the CO is << aesthetically pleasing.

I just got a meter set up at my home and am seeing VOC and CO2 climbing when the heater is running. Going to investigate the ducting and furnace. At this point I’d really like to know the CO levels!

Tying into HomeAssistant to trigger an alarm is a great use case in my book.

Regarding the cost, maybe the business model could include the bespoke choice of sensors that are outside ‘typical’ demand?

Hi everyone, thanks a lot for providing us with your opinion on how we should improve our products.

Please feel free to comment and let us know why you would like us to (or not to) add something to the products.

The US EPA has some very basic guidelines here that speak to time / exposure, and basically says it isn’t easy to measure. That seems like a good reason to try and measure it, especially when there are many sources of exposure that can be serviced, and can occasionally / seasonally change, making it an ongoing point of concern.

Many detectors on the market, like the ones I have, don’t display anything till ~30ppm, making long term / low level exposure impossible to detect. That’s a pernicious problem as it’s just slowly poisoning one’s blood.

@Tai_AirGradient is this a decent sensor to try and integrate? Has your team found a candidate that you like?

2 Likes

Hi @Mike_14.7, thank you for pointing this out.

For the sensor component, let me ask our engineer first and I’ll let you know.

1 Like

Great points @Mike_14.7. My brother was reading literature indicating, like you, that many home alert units do not trigger until the levels are already high enough to be silently poisoning you. He asked for my input on that. Already having an AirGradient One unit, I told him that I would look to see if there were any CO options yet.

Having been a part time firefighter for over 10 years, I would like to add that home alert units usually trigger during the worst time of year, when it is cold, at night. Because the furnace is running overtime. Now the family is standing outside in their PJ’s wondering what to do as we must open up all of their doors and windows and blow fresh, but cold, air into into their home. Now they have a cold house and are unable to turn the heat on. A sensor could be used to catch maintenance issues earlier, like in the fall when the furnace is running a reduced duty cycle.

The bulk doesn’t bother me. What I would like to see in an updated unit is more pluggable modules to tailor it to user concern, or upgrade it over time. This would lower the barrier to entry and accommodate users with different hazard concerns.

Personally, I would rather have a CO sensor than a CO2 sensor. CO2 is something that we produce. Yes, it is harmful to us, that is why we exhale it, but it does not bind to our to our red blood cells like CO does. CO is 200x more likely to bind to hemoglobin than O2 and has a 5hr halflife in blood.

@Tai_AirGradient
Radon is another option that I would like to see for people with basements.

Lastly, an obviously obscure option is an O2 sensor. I have a friend who had an energy efficient house built. He wanted to put in an ERV when it was built, but his contractor told him that he didn’t need it. After he moved in he noticed that his family was always fatigued. He purchased an O2 monitor and found the levels to be low. He put in an ERV post construction, which was way more difficult, but now his family is breathing easy.

O2 levels are usually extremely stable, but as more energy efficient homes are built, I suspect this will become more of an issue.

Hey folks! I’m sorry for my delayed reply. I have asked our engineering team. They are currently working on testing a CO sensor against a reference instrument. We will let you know when we have more progress on this. Thanks!